The Textbook of Architecture

Rules · Optics · Site · Theory

Frame the view like the wings of a stage

Close the picture at one side, or at both, with a dark mass near at hand (a building, a ruin, a clump of trees or a ship), as the painted wings of a stage close its scene; set a feature in the middle distance; and open the centre on a bright distance across water.

Claude Lorrain, Seaport with the Embarkation of Saint Ursula, 1641. A harbour under a low sun. On the left a round temple of Doric columns on steps, with Saint Ursula and her maidens coming down to the quay; beyond it a palace with a tower runs down the quay toward a hazy sun behind a galleon. Ships are moored on the right under tall trees; porters load boats on a landing in the foreground.

The wings of Saint Ursula: the temple at the left and the trees and ships at the right frame the harbour.Claude Lorrain, Seaport with the Embarkation of Saint Ursula, 1641. Oil on canvas, 113 × 149 cm. National Gallery, London (NG30). Photograph: Wikimedia Commons, public domain. The whole scene ↗

In Saint Ursula the round temple fills the left side of the picture, cut off by its frame at the balustrade, and a clump of trees and the moored ships fill the right. The palace and its tower lead the eye down the left of the harbour; the galleon stands in the middle distance; and the centre opens on the sea under the sun. The same arrangement recurs in almost every seaport, and in the landscapes with trees in place of the buildings.

The English landscape gardeners took the arrangement over. Kent and Hoare framed their views of a temple across water with clumps of trees at the sides, as Claude framed his (The garden as a picture).

Related rules

The parterre longer than it is wide

Make the parterre oblong rather than square, since figures somewhat oblong look better on the ground than square ones; later practice made it as broad as the front of the house and about twice as long.

parterre oblong; later practice: width ≈ house front, length ≈ 2 × width

Cite this page Chris Paton, “Frame the view like the wings of a stage”, The Textbook of Architecture, https://textbookofarchitecture.com/rule/claude-framing-wings. Text, drawings and models licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0.